With the new enhancements and layout changes to Facebook I figure it’s high time for me to take some time and get back to ye ol’ blog on UXD here at Nitobi
I must admit that upon a sub-surface evaluation of Layout, Navigation and Interaction Elements, I’m quite impressed with the changes to “The New Facebook”. I do have a few complaints but they’re far outnumbered by worthy improvements and advantages gained so here we go…
1. Removal of arrows for drop down menus
Perhaps they were just ready for a change but I can’t agree with the decision to remove a) the navigation functionality previously made available through the old nav and b) the visual cue suggesting to the user that there is more information hidden under the arrow should they click on it.
The look/feel is cleaner but I see several clear disadvantages:
- removed the ability to select from multiple friend options in drop-down menu
- removed the ability to navigate directly to specific “Inbox” options such as Notifications. If I’m not on the home page, how do I get to them?
I’m sure there is a reason behind this decision and it’s up for debate until one of you out there feels compelled to clear it up for me.
2. Addition of “Applications”
Seems like a logical addition but referencing the applications as “bookmarks” the “Status” container on the home page can be a bit unclear at first. Sure, I can easily figure out what they’re inferring with the icons but some a labeling change to “Application bookmarks” would clear this up greatly. With the previous observation negligible in scale, the major oversight here is that there’s no link in the Applications menu to “Find more applications”.
3. Changed “Profile” to “user.name”
Personally I liked it how it was before because it creeps me out a bit to see my name all over the place. I wonder what the meeting must have been like to justify that change?
The first change I noticed was obvious in that they’ve increased the overall content container width to 964 pixels, a significant increase of 20% from the previous 799 pixel container.
This has gave them a nice advantage to condense the home landing page information vertically and in this case, contrary to my comparison of profile page footprints coming later, they actually increased my home page height, albeit by a negligible amount (134 pixels).
2. Visual changes
It’s nice to have the vertical bounding box removed. The content blocks now “float” in space and IMHO give the entire site a slightly lighter visual feel.
3. News Feed navigation
Having the newly added ability to browse through your News Feed by facet (Top Stories/Status Updates/Photos/Posted Items) is a welcome addition. This feature alone gives them arguably a 4x increase in information density by footprint w/o having to increase total page height. Nice work indeed in terms of IA and UX.
4. Inline Preferences/Editing for content chunks
I love this addition!! Incredibly useful and powerful for the user that will take advantage of it (of course).
. Wall: Edit posts
. News Feed: Set Preferences for a particular Friend being displayed
. Info, Apps, Friends all now have inline preferences found under the “Edit” box
AWESOME enhancement!! I love inline preferences. Incredibly useful.
1. Introduction of new profile navigation
Another addition that I am diggin’ on for various reasons. First and foremost by reworking this page and implementing a sub navigation they effectively reduced the height of my home page by 45.3%!!! (3487px Â» 1907px = 45.3% reduction in Eye Miles to view content). Those numbers are tough to argue with, especially in light of the fact that I now have more information at my disposal than before!
With the sub-nav now enabling inline viewing of Wall, Info, Photos and Boxes users, much like the new nav introduced on the home page for News Feeds, users can now browse 4x the info previously unavailable to access within the old layout. The best feature of this new profile navigation is the sub nav (Share Link – Add Photos – Give Gift – Fun Wall). I specifically like the Photos component that now allows users to create photo albums, post photos and take a photo directly within their profile page. IMHO this is one of the best small changes that they could have made in light of the fact that they have brought users one giant step closer to a core element of sharing experiences through social networking applications, PHOTOS!
Without going into every point in detail here’s my general list of advantages and disadvantages of the new profile navigation:
– Profile page is significantly shorter in height (3487px Â» 1907px = 45.3% reduction)
– Increased customization of profile view
– Greater IA priority and separation given to Photos
– New quick add interaction for creating albums/adding photos gets users that much closer to a core element of sharing experiences through social networking applications
– Unnecessarily disruptive layout changes for navigating to Photos and Boxes.
– Photos page: No interaction element displayed for adding photos, only can Create and Album. They should consider including that interaction element as a component of the “Photos” sub nav which would help maintain the layout consistency and alleviate the disruptive layout change noted above.
The remaining items that I jotted down for the profile page alterations were….
– Wall and Mini Feed have been merged into one stream under “Wall”
– The additional tab in the profile NAV noting a “+” for adding a new tab to the mini-nav. I can infer that I’m able to add something via that interaction element but there’s no hover state indicating what it is until you select it. Small quirk, but easily addressed.
To sum things up I think the Facebook usability crew made some great decisions in the changes that they made to the new version. I’m quite interested to see how they address some of the dangling UI issues I have mentioned and any other once that surface over time as people make the switch. If you made it this far thanks for reading through my comments! Feel free to share yours or debate what I have to say.